http://www.alternet.org/education/why-public-education-needs-teachers-unions?akid=12406.294211.vAUW06&rd=1&src=newsletter1024522&t=19
There are studies that refute the position of the conservatives and
assert that teachers unions have a positive effect on student
achievement. These include work done by researchers Brian Powell, Lala
Carr Steelman and Robert Carini, “ Do Teacher Unions Hinder Educational Performance? Lessons learned from State SAT and ACT Scores,” published in the Harvard Educational Review (Winter 2000), as well as “Teachers’
Unions and Collective Bargaining Agreements: Roadblocks to Student
Achievement & Teacher Quality or Educational Imperatives?” The
study concludes that “…excluding teachers from policy-making is
dangerous because teachers have vital experience and knowledge and
should play a prominent role in policy-making. Teachers are also
essential advocates for their students because their needs are bound up
with the needs of their students to the extent that concessions for
teachers benefit students and enhance teacher quality and student
achievement.”
Finland is a small country that typically scores near the top in the
vaunted international tests. Do teachers unions have any inhibiting
effects on Finland, where 95 percent of teachers are unionized?
According to Pasi Sahlberg, a director at the Finnish Ministry of
Education and Culture and now a visiting professor at Harvard, “Without
the union, we really cannot implement anything. Its role is securing and
protecting the rights of teachers. … It’s a very important part of the
system.”
Another voice on the efficacy of teachers unions is that of the AFT
charter member whose quote begins this essay. You have likely heard of
him. His name was Albert Einstein.
No comments:
Post a Comment